Ready to book your move? Visit CaddyMoving.com

Caddy Moving vs. Thumbtack

Caddy is one in-house moving crew, not a list of independent pros you message for quotes. Thumbtack is a home-services marketplace, not a moving company. You post a job, local pros pay Thumbtack for the lead, then message you quotes.

Side by side

Caddy Moving
Thumbtack
Model
One in-house moving crew.
A home-services marketplace, not a moving company.
Who does the work
Movers hired by Caddy. Typical crew of 2 to 4.
Independent local pros who pay Thumbtack for the lead.
Vetting
Caddy background checks and trains every mover in-house.
Set by each independent pro.
Getting a quote
One quote, one crew.
Post a job. Pros message you quotes. You compare and book one.
Pricing
$50 to $75 per mover per hour.
Set by each pro. Classic jobs are often quoted and paid to the pro.
Fees
2-hour minimum, then half-hour billing.
No membership fee. Pros pay per lead, not a cut of the job.
Payment
Deposit to book; balance after the job. Tips are optional, in cash, and 100% go to the movers.
Classic jobs are often paid to the pro. Instant-book exists in some categories.
Damage and liability
Complimentary general liability.
Set by each independent pro.
Cancellation
Confirm terms with Caddy when booking.
24+ hours ahead: free. Within 24 hours or a no-show: $15.
Availability
Same-day in 90+ cities with a 2-hour lead.
Set by each independent pro.
Support
Live Caddy support on move day.
Through Thumbtack and each pro.

Best for you if you choose Caddy

You need movers to load or unload a U-Haul, PODS or storage unit, with one quote, one crew, same-day service in 90+ cities and live support on move day.

Best for you if you choose Thumbtack

You want to post a job, compare quotes from several local pros, and choose one yourself.

How booking works

With Caddy

  1. 1Get one quote and book your crew with a deposit.
  2. 2Your crew arrives. Same-day service needs a 2-hour lead in 90+ cities.
  3. 3Movers load or unload your U-Haul, PODS or storage unit.
  4. 4Pay the balance after the job. Tips are optional, in cash, and go 100% to the movers.

With Thumbtack

  1. 1Post your job.
  2. 2Local pros pay Thumbtack for the lead, then message you quotes.
  3. 3Compare the quotes and book one pro. Instant-book exists in some categories.
  4. 4Classic jobs are often paid to the pro. Cancel 24+ hours ahead for free.

What to ask any moving-labor provider

These questions apply whichever company you choose.

✓Are the movers employees, or independent providers?
✓Are the movers background checked?
✓What damage or liability coverage is included?
✓What is the minimum, and how is time billed after it?
✓Is the quote firm, and who is paid?
✓When is payment taken?
✓What is the cancellation policy and what does it cost?
✓Can you get a crew the same day?
✓Is there support on move day?

What Caddy customers say

★★★★★

"Same-day, on time, genuinely friendly. They even broke down the boxes after. This is how moving should always feel."

Verified Google review
★★★★★

"Only reason it's four stars is they ran 20 minutes late — but they texted ahead and knocked the time off the bill. Honest crew."

Verified Google review
★★★★★

"Third time using Caddy. Same flat price, same quality, every time. I don't even shop around anymore."

Verified Google review

Read more Google reviews

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Caddy and Thumbtack?

Caddy is one in-house moving crew. Thumbtack is a home-services marketplace, not a moving company.

How does Thumbtack work?

You post a job. Local pros pay Thumbtack for the lead, then message you quotes. You compare and book one.

Does Thumbtack charge a membership fee?

No. Pros pay per lead, not a cut of the job.

How much does Caddy cost?

$50 to $75 per mover per hour with a 2-hour minimum, then half-hour billing. You get one quote and one crew. A typical crew is 2 to 4 movers.

When do I pay?

With Caddy, you pay a deposit to book and the balance after the job. On Thumbtack, classic jobs are often quoted and paid to the pro, and instant-book exists in some categories.

What are the Thumbtack cancellation terms?

Cancel a booking 24 or more hours ahead for free. Within 24 hours, or for a no-show, the charge is $15.

Are the movers vetted?

Caddy background checks and trains every mover in-house, and includes complimentary general liability.

How fast can I get Caddy movers?

Caddy offers same-day service in 90+ cities with a 2-hour lead.

Is there support on move day?

Yes. Caddy has live support on move day.

Ready to book your move?

Book on CaddyMoving.com